Michael`s Italian Restaurant in Elkhart

Food was good but you should not have to wait longer for your check then your food

Very good food and service.

I love eating here! Call ahead for Reservations if you plan on dining on the weekend. Make sure you try the cheese spread (it's made in house)!! It's been one of my favorite foods since I was a little girl! The pizza is also amazing!

Delicious pizza

The prices are reasonable. The food is great. The staff is very friendly.

What makes a great restaurant is not only the great food, but the great people that inhabit it. Everyone is your friend at Michael's from the great staff to the great customers. Have the best pizza (pie to you Italians) in Elkhart! Great sauce, great cheese, and great toppings! My Friday night home away from home. Thanks Rico!

The food, just like your mom made. Maybe better. I won't tell her that though.

Italian sausage is very good. IAdded jalapenos because I love a kick.

The food, staff and owners are beyond top notch. Authentic Italian. Yummm

Best pizza in Elkhart county

On a time crunch, in and out under an hour. Fresh bread with the meal, and friendly guests! They let me seat before hours and hung with the bar crowd. I will be back! And not cause it's convenient!

Celebrated a birthday with family. Great time ...Great food.

Great place. Excellent food and service. Will definitely be returning.

I really liked my pizza. The appetizers were just okay. Quiet place, family friendly atmosphere.

Wonderful food and service. One of my favorite places to eat.

Went for lunch. Had the meatball sandwich, very good. Great server.

It's good. Really good... I had no clue this place existed. But you should go and send me money.

Great food prices right. Their home made salad dressing is a must have. When it is a little busy the service is a little slow but guaranteed worth the wait.

Food and service was excellent!! Atmosphere was wonderful!

Family owned for years and years. If you like real Italian food, you need to eat at Michael's. The house dressing is fantastic. The homemade lasagna is perfect. Don't miss the amazing ribs on Thursday each week.

Tucked away in Elkhart for generations...is this awesome authentic Italian restaurant that reminds me of a big city place where people gather to dine and converse. The food is 5 star...the family thats runs it is kind and generous. Take a minute for lunch or dinner and if you've never been there...you will come back!

Always our favorite Italian to go to. Food is great and service is amazing, even when the place is packed.

We have been going to Michael's since the early 70,s. Although we now live in the South we make a point of going to Michael's when we return to the Elkhart/ South Bend area. As always the food is excellent and the service is personable. You feel like family.

Service was great, food was right on point. Great place for a work lunch appointment.

Best Italian in the area Amazing service and the sweetest family ownership hands down.

Love it! Best gluten free pizza in the area.

Stuffed shells with meatballs , just plain awsome ! 5 stars try it !!!!!!

Great food and service

Great food, service and people!

Good food and drink. What else do you need?

My husband's employer had their Christmas party at Michael's last night. Oh. My. Word. Great food, large portions, and great service. The Eggplant Parmesan was delicious last night and today for lunch. Do order the garlic bread, just lovely. Right now, I am savoring the tiramisu to go. We *will* be back.

Food is excellent! Would highly recommend!

Our first time ordering from Michael's and even with a miss communication on one of the sandwiches l have to say that it was worth the wait. We have lived in Goshen for 20 years and finally had the chance to order. We tried a pizza, bbq ribs sandwiches, breaded mushrooms, fries, and mozzarella sticks. We ordered so much that we have enough for leftovers for dinner tomorrow. Thank you all for a great meal. All the best. J. L. Moss

Outstanding Italian food!! Kids had the chicken strips and I tried one and the best I ever had. Great staff and has that Italian/ Mafia feel like a restaurant should when you eat at a restaurant like Michael's. We will definitely be back again for sure.

Great place to eat good service

Just dropped in on this hidden gem in Elkhart. Great food. Everyone in our party enjoyed their meals. Newly remodeled, neighborhood spot. We loved it

My favorite Pizza in Elkhart, and Elkhart has lots of great places for pizza.

Awesome service. Amazing pizza!

The food was awesome even with a new waitress it was a great experience

First time here. A booming place, that you wouldn't guess from the outside! Our pasta dishes were both bountiful and quite tasty, especially Nicky's Special. Service was friendly and attentive. The Italian bread that came with the meal was disappointing, not much better than Wonder Bread. We would definitely return here.

Great old world Italian restaurant hidden away in Elkhart

Love the food, excellent wait staff, great atmosphere

Bread fantastic staff awesome food out of this world. Authentic Italian restaurant in the middle of Elkhart.

Good place to start Thanksgiving day celebrations. Family in the house.

I love this place! They offer wholesome, homemade food at good prices. The atmosphere is somewhat rustic, inviting and unpretentious. The owner seems to do a little of everything, thus ensuring a good customer experience. I don't get around the area often but I like visiting when I'm out that way.

I've been wanting to try Michael's Italian restaurant for a very long time. A friend of ours (Faith) told us about this restaurant a while ago. She said that their pizza was great. I'm just tired of the same old stuff! Well we decided to try it tonight and weren't disappointed in anyway!! The pizza was so very good! Even being under construction they sure came through constructing my pizza! So good. So excited to go back again! Our first time being there, you've gained new customers, and we will spread the word. Thank you, P. Moss

Great food, great price, friendly staff. After 50 years, why stop now?

Hometown Italian Restaurant. Good idea to have reservations before you go. Great food. A bit loud on weekends

Remodel looks awesome. Great Italian food at good prices

Nice, longtime family owned restaurant atmosphere. Not a lot of privacy for a romantic dinner but a quaint restaurant. Will return!